On top of leg number 4, Bob located the piano’s serial number. The leg is just one place makers put the serial number signifying the year that the piano was made. On grand pianos, the serial number can often be located on the soundboard or under the logo. On upright pianos, the serial number is often stamped on the piano's frame in line with the middle octave. The Antique Piano Shop in Friendsville, Tennessee, helped determine the piano was manufactured in 1854 by looking up the serial number in The Pierce Piano Atlas. In 1839, William Knabe (born Valentin Wilhelm Ludwig Knabe in 1803 in present day Germany) and William Gaehle formed the piano manufacturing firm of Knabe & Gaehle in Baltimore, Maryland. In 1854, Knabe took control of the business and changed the name to William Knabe & Company. The first pianos were manufactured in November 1854, making the square grand at the Bellamy Mansion Museum one of the first produced by the company. There is no bill of sale or easy way to determine when John and Eliza Bellamy actually purchased the piano, and the square grand was often a combination of a custom case sat atop pre-manufactured legs chosen by the buyer.
Article by Wade Toth, Bellamy Mansion Museum Volunteer Coordinator and Leslie Randle-Morton, Bellamy Mansion Museum Associate Director.
0 Comments
FAMILY BEFORE THE WAR To paraphrase Prussian general Carl von Clausewitz: War is a mere continuation of politics by other means. In the context of the Bellamy family and those constructing the home site in Wilmington between 1859 and 1861, the onrushing war and its politics were closely entwined. Some of the architects and builders constructing the Bellamy house saw the social and political issues quite differently from the family. The radical differences of opinion of these many men, expressed sometimes in writing and often in actions, were indicative of the fissures across American society.
Working alongside Bunnell was the New Jersey born lead architect, James F. Post. He had been established in Wilmington since 1849 and was a prolific designer of houses and the 1858 City Hall-Thalian Hall. He used enslaved workers on his projects and participated in slave patrols in the city. At the outbreak of war, he joined the Confederate artillery and later helped build fortifications, barracks and officers' quarters at Fort Anderson and Fort Fisher along the Cape Fear River. Henry Taylor's perspective was as an enslaved carpenter working on construction of the Bellamy site. He was described by Booker T. Washington in The Story of the Negro as, "the son of a white man who was at the same time his master. Although he was nominally enslaved, he was early given liberty to do about as he pleased." Taylor was a successful carpenter–builder before the Civil War. After emancipation, he continued carpentry and ran a grocery store. His later projects included Wilmington's original Hemenway School (c. 1868) and Giblem Masonic Lodge (c. 1871), the first lodge for Blacks in the city and second oldest in the state. He was also a founding member of the Chestnut Street Presbyterian Church and active in local politics, including as a member of the Executive Board of the Colored Union League. After the Civil War, the Colored Union League mobilized newly enfranchised Black voters, working primarily to ensure they remained loyal to the Republican party, providing them with opportunities to debate political and societal issues, negotiate labor contracts, and plan how to care for the sick among them. The Ku Klux Klan’s increasingly successful violent intimidation efforts against White and Black Union Leaguers revealed a deep fear of Republican dominance and perceived Black domination. Taylor's son, Robert, was the first Black graduate from MIT, in architecture, and he was featured on a 2015 US postage stamp for his pioneering role. His great-great granddaughter is Valerie Jarrett, who served as Senior Advisor to President Barack Obama, and her daughter Laura Jarrett was a CNN correspondent and now is a contributing legal journalist on NBC. In the immediate postwar years, other builders of the Bellamy site became prominent in civic life, including the Howe and Sadgwar families. Perhaps most prominent in local politics was George W. Price Jr., who had daringly escaped by boat on the Cape Fear River in 1862 alongside enslaved plasterer William B. Gould and six others. The men were picked up by a Union ship and joined the Union Navy. On his return to his native city as a veteran, Price promptly became a leading Republican figure. He was elected to the city board of aldermen in 1868, served in the state legislature from 1869 through 1872, and became city marshal and justice of the peace in 1874 and for several years thereafter. Union veteran Gould headed north after the war and settled in Dedham, Massachusetts, with his wife Cornelia, also formerly enslaved in Wilmington. Their great-great-grandson William B. Gould IV is an emeritus Stanford University law professor and served as chair of the National Labor Relations Board under President Bill Clinton. POLITICIANS IN WARTIME
After the occupation of Wilmington in February 1865, the Federal government seized all of Dr. Bellamy's property, including his highly profitable naval stores operations in Columbus County, Grovely Plantation in Brunswick County, his stores and buildings in Wilmington, and the residence on Market and 5th. Bellamy enslaved 115 people, many on these plantation businesses. We unfortunately do not know much of what happened in the lives of these populations. Throughout the summer of 1865, Bellamy worked to gain the necessary pardon and to reclaim his business properties and home. He finally received a presidential pardon, signed by President Andrew Johnson. Johnson himself was the last President to own enslaved people and is noted for allowing white supremacy to regain power in the post-war South. In the summer of 1874, as Reconstruction faltered, son John Bellamy Jr. returned home after graduating from the University of Virginia law school. The new minister of First Presbyterian Church, which the Bellamy family attended, was Joseph Ruggles Wilson, the father of Thomas Woodrow Wilson. John Jr. became a friend and tutor to young Wilson, then of college age. The two young men shared an interest in books and history, and Tommy (as he was fondly called) spent many hours at the Bellamy home before leaving Wilmington to study at Princeton. Woodrow Wilson later served as president of Princeton University and as the governor of New Jersey before winning the 1912 presidential election. From 1913 to 1921, he was the 28th President of the United States. His domestic policies as President were notably segregationist and his expressed opinions marked him an apologist for slavery and a supporter of the lost cause myth. POST-WAR FAMILY Illustrative of how Civil War politics lingered well past Reconstruction is the career of John D. Bellamy Jr. He became a prominent Wilmington attorney and served as a State Senator before running for US Congress during the White supremacy campaign of 1898. In 1898 a statewide effort by Democrats to regain elected positions from Black politicians used voter intimidation, propaganda, voter suppression, and fear mongering to win elections "by whatever means." John Jr. did win the election, but it was so clearly fraudulent that the man he beat, Oliver Dockery, contested the election results. He sought witnesses and evidence for a case that sought a Congressional hearing into the election and the murders that took place in Wilmington two days later. The Wilmington Massacre -- where an unknown number of Black citizens were killed and run out of town by White assailants -- was part of the only successful coup d'etat in American history. It removed a multi-racial 'fusionist' city government, erased the burgeoning African American middle-class, and instituted a white supremacist government by force. Events in Wilmington led to a sea-change across the state and was a facet of the replacement of Reconstruction with Jim Crow. John Jr. claimed in his diary not to be in town during the massacre but it is highly likely he aided in the planning leading up to the events. John Jr. had already served as a Democrat in the North Carolina Senate (1891-1892) and joined the US House of Representatives from 1899-1903. He was a delegate to the National Democratic Convention in 1892, 1908, and 1920. He also served as a delegate to the Washington Disarmament Conference in 1924 and 1932. In 1936, he was selected to cast the electoral vote of North Carolina for Franklin D. Roosevelt.
Of Dr. Bellamy's six sons, the only other politician was George Bellamy. He was also a farmer and ran Grovely Plantation in Brunswick County for his father after it became a post-war sharecropping enterprise. George was active in the county's politics earning him the nickname the "Duke of Brunswick." According to his brother John Jr., George "served many times as legislator in the Lower House and also in the Senate, until he was appointed US Marshal for the Eastern District of North Carolina." These sketches of some of the figures related to the history of the museum site come from The Bellamy Mansion Mansion: Wilmington, North Carolina by Catherine Bishir (2004), Memoirs of an Octogenarian by John Bellamy, Jr. (1942), Back with the Tide, Memoirs of Ellen Douglas Bellamy (2002) and excerpts of the diaries of Rufus Bunnell. As a point of interpretation it is important to recall that memoirs inherently reflect the biases of their authors and are not objective. Researched and written by Leslie Randle-Morton, Bellamy Mansion Museum Associate Director. Fall—when days get shorter, leaves change color, and pumpkin spice reigns. It is also the time of year when the sublime and spooktacular seep into every corner of our lives. More things seem to go bump in the night and houses, especially old houses, are presumed extra haunted and active. But in the world of historic house museums, it’s like Halloween year-round as ghosts and ghouls are always on visitors’ minds. Museum goers of every age, every culture, and every background ask Bellamy Museum staff and volunteers daily about the supposed spooks and historic haunts on property—and some even come back from tours with stories of their own. Sometimes a visitor has an experience they did not expect and did not seek out. This summer a Marine came back with photos of light anomalies he captured on the children’s level of the main house after a seemingly normal self-guided tour. A mother recently came into the visitor center visibly shaken because her child, whom she claims is sensitive to spirits, was so upset by what he felt and saw in the house, he ran out crying. Some visitors come with the expressed desire of encountering the paranormal while they tour, and on the most extreme end are those visitors who rent the site to conduct para-scientific “investigations” in an attempt to get to the bottom of the ghostly goings-on. The question is why do so many people not only assume the site is haunted but desire it to be haunted…almost need it to be haunted? Why do vacationers seek out death during their down time? This article attempts to shed light on why modern visitors spend their leisure time and discretionary income in the pursuit of what has become known as “dark tourism.”[1] Paranormal Popularity: Ghosts in Modern America The concept of the ghost is universal,[2] yet expressions of ghosts are culturally constructed according to the needs of a particular culture at a particular time. Ghost stories have been used by societies in myriad ways including as discursive metaphors, as moral warnings, and as vehicles of social ritual. According to media professor John Potts, the ghost as an idea is utilized as a solution to a problem; it is an answer to a question.[3] The concept of the ghost, the solution, does not change, but its performative function evolves as cultural challenges evolve over time. From a scholarly perspective it is pointless to postulate whether ghosts are real or not. What is important is how ghosts and their corresponding stories culturally function. In the 21st century, the paranormal seems as popular as ever and can be found in many facets of American culture beyond books and movies. Reality television series such as Ghost Hunters, Paranormal Witness, and Ghost Adventures have multiplied in recent years and now ghostly programming is offered by almost every major cable channel. Even scripted forensic dramas such as The Ghost Whisperer and Medium achieved popularity in a post-9/11 America that assuaged new anxieties with detectives who could see the unseen.[4] The internet is awash with websites selling ghost hunting equipment and promising definitive paranormal proof, one goal of which is to recruit would-be ghost hunters. The thirst for paranormal experiences has spilled over into other free-choice learning environments where an amalgam of walking ghost tours, haunted reenactments, and cemetery tours are a short walk or a leisurely drive away for most Americans. History museums have not been spared from America’s obsession with all things paranormal. John Potts argues this is partly because ghosts “are representations of the past as [they] endure in the present. To be haunted by a ghost is to be haunted by the past.”[5] And in this age where younger visitors desire an experience for their Instagram story over a boring old souvenir, being haunted by the past is all the rage. Death and Disney: Visitor Motivations and Learning in Museums Visitor study researcher John Falk offers a possible explanation as to why Americans seek out ghosts during their leisure time. He explains that many 21st century citizens focus on the higher ends of Maslow’s hierarchy of needs: security, self-esteem, and self-fulfillment. The struggles for food, shelter, and warmth are no longer major driving motivations in developed nations, and moving up Maslow’s hierarchy is now enacted through leisure rather than work including in free-choice leisure learning environments like museums. Americans expect their spiritual, cultural, and intellectual needs to be simultaneously met during their leisure time in a type of “consumptive multi-tasking”[6] which are congruous to the overlapping motivations of the personal, the sociocultural, and the physical which Falk and Lynn Dierking argue each visitor brings to a free-choice learning setting.[7] These qualitative shifts in leisure needs have given rise to a quantitative explosion of leisure opportunities, and visitors exert choice and control over where they go and what they learn. According to Falk, this control fuels self-actualization and feeds the higher end of Maslow’s hierarchy creating and affirming personal identity. So, when a visitor chooses a certain museum or a specific guided tour, they are essentially affirming who they are through their leisure activities.[8] But why do visitors expect all old buildings, especially historic house museums, to be busting at the seams with specters, and why are they so bummed out if we tell them they’re not? From Pilgrimages to Post-Modern Angst: The History of Thanatourism For centuries, humans worked through the emotional, spiritual, and psychological effects of death, dying, and the afterlife within formal settings such as the church, but one fairly-new lens through which to examine the modern American fascination with death and the paranormal is that of the burgeoning, yet sometimes problematic, study of “thanatourism,”[9] or “dark tourism.” First touched upon in the early 1990’s by Chris Rojek, who discussed tourism’s ‘black spots,’[10] the term thanatourism was first coined by Anthony Seaton in 1996. Seaton defines thanatourism as “…travel to a location wholly, or partially, motivated by the desire for actual or symbolic encounters with death… particularly, but not exclusively, violent death…,” although this interest in violence only developed over time.[11] Seaton argues that this interest represents a metamorphosis of thanatopsis—the contemplation of death itself, an almost universal concern. According to Seaton, thanatopsis became thanatourism as pilgrimages to sites of martyrdom and holy shrines became stylish for the eighteenth-century European elites. In the early stages of thanatourism, the supply side was spontaneous such as battlefields or sites of executions, and often religious in nature. Visitors were focused on the idea of death itself rather than the manner of death. This defining characteristic evolved during the Romantic period as science began to obfuscate religion which, according to Seaton, dislodged thanatopsis from the church, and thanatourists became motivated by a spiritual need to “…make death a highly normal and present element in every-day life…”[12] Thanatourism continued to develop, even with deliberateness, involving both historical and contemporary sites. The Romantic notions of the Sublime, the Other, the Gothic and Black Romanticism further transformed thanatourism through the abandonment of “older notions of communal morality and belief…” and the development of “a secular taste for murder and violence…”[13] As a result, the particular manner of death began to matter as much as the notion of death itself. The Battle of Waterloo in 1815 was one of the first major sites for thanatourists. According to researcher Anthony Seaton, "No other battle attracted comparable public attention or detonated such an immediate spate of visitation—so immediate, in fact, that it started while the battle was actually taking place." Image courtesy of Getty Images. In addition to defining and explaining thanatourism, Seaton also developed a five-part taxonomy, based on a spectrum of intensity: 1. Travel to watch death 2. Travel to sites after death has occurred 3. Travel to internment sites and memorials 4. Travel to re–enactments 5. Travel to synthetic sites at which evidence of the dead has been assembled Philip Stone has also recently elaborated on Seaton’s categorization of intensity, suggesting that sites associated with death are situated at the lighter end of the spectrum while sites of death are situated at the darkest end. [14] Tourism scholar Graham Dann alliteratively extended Seaton’s categories without considering a spectrum of intensity to include:
While Seaton analyzed the development of dark tourism in antiquity, other scholars have considered the topic of dark tourism as a modern manifestation. John Lennon and Malcolm Foley maintain that thanatourism is an exclusively modern manifestation which grew out of early twentieth-century industrialization, universal suffrage, and the spread of education in America. These hallmarks of modernity gave some the “wealth and freedom to travel and the education to benefit from the experience,”[16] spawning a tourism industry that encompassed travel, accommodations and attractions. In spite of their interpretive disagreements, Anthony Seaton and John Lennon joined forces in 2004 in order to further expound on the definition of dark tourism. Blending their understanding of dark tourism, they acknowledge that “mass media have largely usurped the function of the church as an institution with the power to sacralize people and places as targets of devotional travel.”[17] They further remark that contemporary members of developed societies feel a need to find new ways to connect with death, as modern hospitals, nursing homes and funeral parlors have served to privatize death and erode its place in the modern collective mind. With death separated from everyday life, the “media and tourism [now] offer opportunities for legitimate, vicarious contact with death”[18] and visitors often believe we museum professionals are just hiding the truth about ghosts from them. Death in the American home was once common, and many Americans were born, lived, and died in the same house. Holding wakes and funerals in the home was also standard. As hospitals and mortuaries grew in popularity, the average American no longer experienced closeness with death to the same degree, and Americans began to seek out experiences with death in other ways. Image courtesy of Getty Images. Into the Light: Victorian Spiritualism and the Afterlife Seaton and Lennon argue that secularization and anxieties associated with the processes and products of modernity play a part in visitor motivation to sites of dark tourism, but they leapfrog neatly over major modern societal developments of which we are still heirs—namely the evolution of modern religion that came about during the 19th-century and man’s quest for proof of the afterlife. Just like thanatourism, the exact origins of American Spiritualism are elusive. Spiritualism, “a popular religious practice conducted through communication with the spirits of the dead,”[19] contained traces of Shakerism, Quakerism, mesmerism as well as tenets of some lesser known fringe groups like the followers of the mid-eighteenth century mystic Emanuel Swedenborg. Swedenborg attempted to use theology as empirical proof of man’s immortal soul. His practical blending of empirical scientific thought with the reading of Scripture led Swedenborgians to believe that there was an absolute truth beyond man’s external senses. The mystic laid out a detailed geography of heaven that both Swedenborgians and later Spiritualists used to explain communing with the spirits and their objections to the formation of formal churches. Swedenborgians eventually succumbed to a formal church system and rejected communication with spirits which is why some historians give the Swedish mystic credit for planting the “cosmic seeds of a system”[20] without actually giving him credit for the Spiritualist movement itself. Most historians maintain that the true timeline of American Spiritualism can be traced to 1848, on a New York farm, where two sisters, Kate and Margaret Fox, began communing with Mr. Splitfoot, the spirit of a murdered peddler who had died in their home. Through raps, taps, and various knocks, Mr. Splitfoot answered the girls’ questions in conversations that were more personal than any spirit communication Swedenborgians or Shakers experienced. The Fox sisters maintained that they operated a “spiritual telegraph”[21] through which messages could be received from and sent to spirits. Unlike that of Quakers and Swedenborgians, the Fox sisters’ communication methods and messages were of a more personal nature which, when considered with the cultural and historical confluences of antebellum America including sectarianism, revivalism, African religious influences, and utopian experimental societies, help explain why within a few short years American Spiritualism was ubiquitous. Séances were held from coast to coast where spirits rapped, levitated, and spoke through mediums delivering everything from benign messages of comfort for surviving loved ones to portents of doom in a rapidly industrializing society. According to historian Molly McGarry, Spiritualism, which began “as a children’s ghost story, and later as an after-dinner entertainment, quickly became a popular national phenomenon and a powerful new religion.”[22] This religion did not require faith, but merely asked potential devotees to investigate the spiritual plane, which could therefore prove the existence of an eternal spirit, and Spiritualism’s need was “unflagging—and at times desperate—in its effort to prove survival.”[23] This blending of new scientific thought with mystical elements of traditional religion exemplified the Victorian struggle with modernity in a society in which the traditional was seen as being quickly supplanted by the innovative. Spiritual mediums even imbued modern technologies with magical properties as they channeled human telegraphs and produced spectral photography. This dichotomous belief in unseen forces and the need for scientific proof of their existence is embodied today in what John Potts describes as the “enlightened believer.”[24] Ghost hunters, equipped with electromagnetic field monitors, full spectrum cameras, and electronic voice phenomenon recorders are simply secular late modern versions of 19th century Spiritualists “who firmly suspect that ghosts and other supernatural phenomenon do exist, but that plausible evidence must be found for them, based on empirical evidence.”[25] Historian Robert S. Cox elaborates on the performative nature of Spiritualism to include Victorians’ search for personal identity through the notion of soulmates. To find one’s authentic self, men and women began opting for sympathetic relationships based on love and interconnectedness rather than societal pressures of status or socioeconomic assuredness. Spiritualists espoused the benefits of free love and sympathetic, referred to by Spiritualist A.B. Child as “soul affinity.”[26] Spiritualists who adopted Child’s fascination with soul affinity believed that every person on earth has a spiritual counterpart but understood that the pitfalls of the mortal world might inhibit true soul affinity until after the spirit departed the body. They maintained that two destined souls could never truly be separated. This Victorian emergence of mutual love and a bond everlasting bestowed ghost stories with a reoccurring theme recognizable still: lost love. Doomed spirits, usually sad Victorian women robed in long white or gray dress, are destined to wander the cliffs, or the widow’s walk, or the cemetery in an eternal search for their soulmate. One longtime Bellamy volunteer who has been involved with the site since before it was even a museum has his own “lady in grey” story about a forlorn ghost he claims many used to see wandering the rooms in the main house. Spiritualism and the idea of soul affinity did more for 19th century women than turn them into forlorn spectral protagonists of Victorian ghost tales. The idea of a soulmate made women spiritually necessary. Spiritualist discussions of a balanced universe emphasized equally the importance of men and women. Female mediums channeled spirits who delivered radical messages on topics from marital rape to women’s role in public office. The most visible evidence of “the link between female empowerment and Spiritualism is the historic connection between suffragism and Spiritualism.”[27] Not all Spiritualists were suffragists or vice versa, but the first suffrage leaders in America noted that Spiritualism embraced the equality of women with a zeal yet unheard in antebellum America. Elizabeth Cady Stanton and Susan B. Anthony acknowledged the religion’s positive position on women in suffragist writings. Spiritualist newspapers openly advocated for women’s rights, and female mediums commanded public speaking platforms. The end of the era of Spiritualism with a capital “S” cannot be neatly packaged. Some historians, like Robert S. Cox, determined the 1870’s as the twilight years of American Spiritualism asserting that the half million casualties of the Civil War did not speak through mediums with any amount of fervor found in antebellum America.[28] Others, like Molly McGarry, asserted that Spiritualism continued, though fractured, through the beginning of the twentieth century because “the ghost is a powerful way of understanding memory and identity.”[29] Even if Spiritualism as a religion faded way, the search for an afterlife has not. In a 1993 article for the Journal for the Scientific Study of Religion, Brian Harley and Glenn Firebaugh found that over 70% of Americans believe in some form of an afterlife. In fact, the overall trend in Americans’ belief in an afterlife rose, although slightly, between 1970 and 1990.[30] There is evidence, from the proliferation of pseudoscientific ghost hunting societies to Americans’ insistence in belief of an afterlife that remnants of 19th-century Spiritualism are still at work in American society today. The Spiritualist movement had an impact on 19th century women as it made them necessary in new ways--as "soulmates" and as mediums. Elizabeth Cady Stanton and Susan B. Anthony acknowledged the religion’s positive position on women in suffragist writings, and Spiritualist newspapers championed ideas of women's equality. Images courtesy of the Library of Congress. Paranormally Perceived: Opportunities and Obstacles of a “Haunted” Historic Site
So it seems pushing back on visitors’ desire to encounter death and life after death at historic sites would just be an exercise in futility, so how do museum professionals harness this deep, intrinsic visitor motivation, and should they? The majority of museumgoers is under the age of fifty[31] and is more accustomed to “curating culture” and filtering personal preferences through mass media avenues like Facebook and Instagram. As institutions like print newspaper and fraternal organizations decline, websites like Reddit and YouTube continue to gain popularity because, like other leisure options, the user has choice and control of what content to explore along with the option to give feedback or engage in discussion with likeminded users. These qualities appeal to the population that already makes up the majority of museum visitors, and museums need to respond to these “extremely creative consumers”[32] lest they run the risk of losing them to other leisure options. Historic sites and museums that offer ghost tours, historic happy hour, adult arts and crafts, and other specialized classes or tours are tapping into modern visitors’ personal, sociocultural, and physical needs of consumptive control, self-actualization, and identity making, but it remains to be seen if these offerings fulfill the educative mandates inherent in museum mission statements and programming goals. An area dark tourism can have a continued, positive impact is when it comes to a museum’s bottom line. So many historic house museums, the Bellamy Museum included, are not-for-profit organizations or run by small nonprofits which receive no state or federal funds. Revenue comes from grant writing, donations, admissions, and after-hours private rentals. This means a site’s ability to host weddings, business meetings, and even paranormal investigations can be an integral part of the annual budget. Most recently the Bellamy Museum leaned into people’s deathly desires not by offering ghost tours ourselves, but by renting to ghost hunting companies like Haunted Rooms America who offer anyone the ghost hunter experience in historic places across the U.S. for a fee. Haunted Rooms America will hold six overnight investigations at the Bellamy site in 2025. Please note the Bellamy Mansion Museum does not allow any investigating in the site’s original slave quarters building. These groups only have access to the main house on property. With investigations come “evidence” which often lives in perpetuity on online platforms. These videos, photographs, and “electronic voice phenomenon” shape a narrative outside the purview of museum professionals and an educational mission, so when a visitor asks “Is this place haunted?” the official answer is important lest people confuse the interpreted for the inferred. At the Bellamy Museum we often answer that question with an identity affirming, “if you believe ghosts are here, then they are, and if you do not, they are not.” Interested in hearing more about the supposed spooks at local sites like the Bellamy Museum and positioning documented historical education alongside the public's interest in the supernatural? Check out the podcast link “Burgwin-Wright Presents: Haunted Tales of the Cape Fear” from our friends at the Burgwin-Wright House and Gardens—Wilmington’s oldest historic home open to the public. BWH Assistant Director Hunter Ingram talks with Leslie Randle-Morton of the Bellamy Museum about their experiences. ___________________________________________________________________________________________________________ [1] John Lennon and Malcolm Foley, two professors of hospitality, tourism and leisure management at Glasgow Caledonian University first coined the term in the late 1990s. Their first full length exploration and analysis of this phenomenon was Dark Tourism: The Attraction of Death and Disaster published in 2000. [2] John Potts, “The Idea of the Ghost,” in Technologies of Magic, ed. John Potts and Edward Scheer (Sydney: Power Publications, 2006), 82. [3] Potts, 79. Potts draws on the evolution of intellectual historians such as Collingwood, Focault, and Kuhn in acknowledging that ideas are not unchanging but are dynamic in their historical function and require contextualization rather than just a moniker (the name attached to an idea) to truly understand them. [4] Ann McGuire and David Buchbinder, “The forensic gothic: Knowledge, the supernatural, and the psychic detective.” Canadian Review of American Studies 40, no. 3 (2010): 290. [5] Potts, 83. [6] John H. Falk, Identity and the Museum Visitor Experience (Walnut Creek: Left Coast Press, 2009), 43. [7] John Falk and Lynn Dierking, Learning from Museums (Walnut Creek: AltaMira Press, 2000), 13. [8] Falk, 41-45. [9] Anthony Seaton, “Guided by the Dark,” International Journal of Heritage Studies 2, no. 4 (1996). [10] Chris Rojek, Ways of Escape (London: MacMillan, 1993), 136. [11] Seaton, 240. [12] Seaton, 237. [13] Seaton, 237. [14] Richard Sharpley, “Shedding Light on Dark Tourism,” in The Darker Side of Travel, ed. by Richard Sharpley and Philip Stone (Bristol: Channel View Publications, 2009), 20. The chart was scanned directly from the book. [15] Graham Dann, “The Dark Side of Tourism,” Etudes et Rapports L, no. 14 (1998): 3. [16] Lennon and Foley, 7. [17] Anthony Seaton and John Lennon, “Thanatourism in the Early 21st Century,” in New Horizons in Tourism, ed. Tej Vir Singh (Oxfordshire: CABI Publishing, 2004), 69. [18] Seaton and Lennon, 70. [19] Molly McGarry, Ghosts of Future Past (Berkeley: Univ. of California Press, 2008), 1. [20] Robert Cox, Body and Soul (Charlottesville: Univ. of Virginia, 2003), 12-13. [21] McGarry, 2. [22] Ibid, 2. [23] Roy Stemman, Spirits and Spirit Worlds (London: Danbury Press, 1975), 26. [24] John Potts, “The Idea of the Ghost,” in Technologies of Magic, ed. John Potts and Edward Scheer (Sydney: Power Publications, 2006), 82. [25] Potts, 86. [26] Robert Cox, Body and Soul (Charlottesville: Univ. of Virginia, 2003), 95. [27] McGarry, 46-49. [28] Cox, 233. [29] McGarry, 175. [30] Brian Harley and Glenn Firebaugh, “Americans’ Belief in an Afterlife,” in Journal for the Scientific Study of Religion 32, no. 3 (1993), 269-278. The study analyzed answers from over 16,000 Americans who identified as Christians, both Protestant and Catholic, Jews, “None”, and “Other.” [31] Susie Wilkening and James Chung, Life Stages of the Museum Visitor (Washington, DC: AAM,2009), 7. [32] Wilkening and Chung, 145. Contributed by Bellamy Museum Board Member Lynn Wood Mollenauer, Ph.D. Associate Professor, Department of History, University of North Carolina Wilmington The 1859 Bellamy Museum slave quarters is a rare surviving and interpreted example of this type of urban structure. During the multi-year restoration of the slave quarters, archeologists discovered a cache of small objects under the floorboards of the first story bedchamber. The assortment included buttons, a bead or two, an animal’s jawbone, a shard of pottery, and parts of a child’s doll. While we cannot definitively identify it as such, it is likely that this collection of seemingly mundane items is a ritual concealment. A ritual concealment, sometimes called a spiritual cache, is a hidden collection of objects intended for protection. The objects are typically ordinary things that to modern eyes seem to lack religious or spiritual significance. Ritual concealments have been deposited for centuries across North America and Europe and are part of African cultural traditions as well. The earliest European examples are pre-Roman; deposits containing animal skeletons, coins, and bottles have been excavated from buildings that date from the Bronze Age forward. Concealments were secreted under windows and doorways to safeguard homes or embedded in walls and hearths during construction to ward off evil and misfortune. In North America, European colonists continued the long-standing practice, bricking up dolls, shoes, knives, pieces of clothing, horse skulls, and even dead cats in the belief that the hidden items would ensure the well-being of the building’s inhabitants. (We know the cats were placed deliberately, as they were often posed with rodents in their mouths.) Excavations on antebellum plantations reveal that enslaved peoples too left ritual deposits, which might contain beads, nails or other pieces of iron, and ceramic shards.
Evidence from newspapers and novels suggests that North Carolinians also used amulets and charms for supernatural protection. In Charles W. Chestnutt’s 1901 Wilmington-based novel, The Marrow of Tradition, for example, the character Aunt Jane buries a charm in her employers’ backyard during a full moon. The charm, provided by a conjure woman living on the edge of town, is meant to keep the baby boy Aunt Jane looks after safe from harm. Its contents included calamus root, a bone from a black cat, and a vial of water in which the baby had been bathed. Amulets, sometimes called “conjure bags,” were charms that were most often worn around the neck. They were believed to ward off disease and other manifestations of ill will, as well as to help defendants in court. Newspaper articles from the time indicate that the use of conjure bags was not at all uncommon. As the Wilmington Messenger reported of accused arsonist John Braswell, “he had two conjure bags with him in court . . . and relied on them more than his lawyers.” (March 3, 1898) The reporter seemed to take some satisfaction in noting that John Braswell was nonetheless found guilty. The slave quarters at the Bellamy site was built in 1859, mostly by enslaved workers, and sporadically occupied into the 1930s. It sat empty for decades and a new roof was placed by the family in the 1980s. When Preservation NC became involved in 1989 maintenance work occurred gradually as the museum evolved. The building has been featured on the museum tour since 1994 in various stages of repair. A complete restoration was undertaken in 2013-14 to return the building to its original condition. Intriguingly, the slave quarters of the Bellamy Museum may have even more ritual deposits hidden within its walls. Chunks of obsidian and shards of broken china, embedded in the mortar of the east and south walls, were discovered during the 2013-14 restoration. They too may be evidence of a ritual meant to protect the building’s inhabitants. The Bellamy Museum is fortunate to be one of the most photographed and artistically rendered sites in Wilmington. The list of local notables creating images include Ben Billingsley, Bruce Bowman, Todd Carignan, John and Mary Ellen Golden, Claude Howell, William Mangum, Louis Orr, John Poon, Robert Powers, and many others. Several are in our collection, including a large-scale image by regionalist artist Chris Wilson that has been added recently. Also, countless fine photographers and 3D artists have approached the subject, along with more unusual renditions in woodcut, models, ice sculpture, and even cakes! Artist Chris Wilson: The Bellamy Through His Eyes The moment you enter Kathy Wilson’s modern,1,300-square-foot apartment overlooking the Cape Fear River in downtown Wilmington, you are ensconced in a world of art and antiques. The walls are filled with “postcards” (small versions of much larger paintings), sketches, studies and other large-scale artworks, most of which were created by Kathy’s late husband J. Chris Wilson (1948-2023), an American Southern regionalist artist, best known for his paintings of North Carolina scenic landscapes. In her new living space, Kathy has lovingly curated selections of her husband's art to memorialize the span of their lives. Chris painted it in 2008, a few years after moving to Wilmington from Rocky Mount, NC, where he and Kathy, both college professors, restored the 18th-century Battle family Old Town plantation. It was purchased from Preservation North Carolina (PNC), and soon after added to the National Register of Historic Places. Passionate preservationists, they took three years to restore the Wilmington house, and Chris served a stint on the PNC board while Kathy was a member of the board of the Bellamy Mansion Museum representing PNC. During this time, Chris and Kathy were recipients of the Gertrude S. Carraway Award of Merit in 2011 from PNC for their contributions to historic preservation. Soon after Chris’ passing in late 2023, Kathy donated the Bellamy piece to the museum, where 22,000 annual visitors can enjoy the beauty of Chris’ interpretation of the iconic 1861 mansion and 1921 Kenan fountain. Kathy explains the donation is in honor of her husband's dedication to preservation, as well as that of recently retired PNC President Myrick Howard. As to what drew him to paint the Bellamy, Chris has said: “I’m looking for extraordinary landscapes, things that are extraordinary in terms of visual interest, and that will make a really good painting. And so I’m not really seeking out the best known tourist sites in North Carolina and then doing those because it’s not the site that I’m after, it’s the composition and design I’m after, it’s what interests me.”
In the early 2000's, Chris began working on his most prolific project: "From Murphy to Manteo—An Artist's Scenic Journey," traveling across North Carolina numerous times, photographing and sketching potential compositions. His stated goal was to produce 100 large-scale canvases, some with dimensions approaching 16 feet, depicting scenes from the mountains to the sea. The series was named for U.S. Route 64, the longest highway in North Carolina measuring 563 miles. Chris passed away before that project was finished, but he has most certainly left behind an enduring legacy.
Mirrors at the level of the gas fixtures were used, as were mirrors low to the ground. Sometimes they were built into furniture or into fireplace covers like the ones on display in the mansion. The covers, which were placed in front of the open fireplace any time it was not in use, were not used for women to check their ankle exposure, as an old wives' tale suggests, but to provide more light for everyone in the parlor. The entire Bellamy house was plumbed for gas when finished in 1861 and both wall-mounted and ceiling gas fixtures were placed in hallways and the nine bedrooms. The gasolier in the Bellamy's family parlor, shown below left, was made by Cornelius and Baker of Philadelphia. It is especially appealing with little cherubs blowing horns and decorative elements, including circus elephants. Given Dr. Bellamy's politics, it may be no coincidence that this gasolier is quite similar to the one also made by Cornelius and Baker in the White House of the Confederacy in Richmond, Va. (1861-1865). This gasolier is possibly one of seven attributed in 1896 to the original furnishings of the White House.
The Mirrors
Each mirrored fireplace cover in the Bellamy parlors has the maker’s mark “T. Bent & Son N.Y No. 18” on its back. Thomas Bent established the Globe Iron Foundry in 1843 in New York, NY. The company was well known for their stable and kennel fixtures and fittings. In 1860 Dr. and Mrs. Bellamy may have visited the Globe Iron Foundry at their 26th Street Manhattan shop to purchase not only the fireplace covers but also stable fittings for the carriage house and possibly decorative iron benches for outside. Thomas Bent died in 1870 and his son Samuel took over the company. By 1890 Samuel had moved the foundry from New York City to Port Chester where it became Samuel S. Bent & Son. (Source: The Iron Age, Vol. 46, September 1890.)
A lonely, dirty, dangerous business: Extracting this 'pine tar' is described by historian David Cecelski; "A 'boxed tree' was one that had a section of its bark cut away so that the resin flowed into the hollow in the tree where it could be collected. To make 'spirits of turpentine,' the woodsmen and women (often enslaved laborers) collected and distilled that resin, not terribly unlike making liquor." [2] Given that pine resin featured in so many products, plus preserved wood and waterproofed ships, it was unsurprising that North Carolina, one of the world's leading sources, accumulated so much wealth from its pine trees. As lucrative as it was for the White land owners, the industry could be solitary and physically taxing for the enslaved workers. The industry used the task system. An overseer assigned enslaved workers a task, or multiple tasks, and they were responsible for completing them. This meant an enslaved naval stores worker could continue with limited or no supervision for several days at a stretch. Shoes, hats and blankets were often the only items enslaved workers on these turpentine farms had that were not made on site. Different from plantation life, where families were often housed together, laboring in a turpentine operation could be more solitary with perhaps only a small number of female enslaved cooks with the male laborers. Working conditions were harsh. Summer heat, mosquitoes, poisonous snakes and poison ivy, among much else, were prevalent and led to a variety of maladies. Wet ground and forests made it difficult if not impossible to move carts led by mules.
When enslaved people would stir pine tar, pitch and turpentine, it was often in huge cauldrons that required them to stand on the edge and use a long stirrer, almost like an oar. One slip could lead to severe burning. In this case, being a “Tar Heel” was certainly not a good thing. In 1850 there were 1,144 distillers of pine tar products in the state, and most had businesses in Wilmington. By 1860 the value of this trade was over $5 million. [5] To that point, an unproven story, likely an apocryphal boast but certainly indicative, relayed by John Bellamy Jr. in his manuscript, Memoirs of an Octogenarian (readable here), was that one year's profit from one of his father's plantations paid for the Bellamy house in Wilmington. As with cotton and rice plantations on the Cape Fear the hard work of enslaved Black workers was central to this egregiously unequal economy and society.
[1] William S. Powell (March 1982). "What's in a Name? Why We're All Called Tar Heels". Tar Heel magazine
[2] David Cecelski (reviewing 1809 diary excerpts from English traveler Holles Bull Way), Coastal Review article, July 2018, coastalreview.org.https://coastalreview.org/2018/07/pitch-pines-and-tar-burners-a-1792-account/ [3] Dr. Lloyd Johnson. https://northcarolinahistory.org/encyclopedia/naval-stores/ [4] David Cecelski (reviewing 1809 diary excerpts from English traveler Holles Bull Way), Coastal Review article, July 2018, coastalreview.org.https://coastalreview.org/2018/07/pitch-pines-and-tar-burners-a-1792-account/ [5] Dr. Lloyd Johnson. https://northcarolinahistory.org/encyclopedia/naval-stores/ [6] Article, WUFT Public Media, Veronica Nocera. May 9, 2024. www.tuft.org/environment/2024-05-09/the-trees-truth-once-dominant-longleaf-pines-face-the-growing-threat-of-climate-change
Don’s fascination with the Bellamy Mansion began in 1968, Sharpe observed, when he traveled to Wilmington for the Azalea Festival air show. As he rode past the mansion it captured his imagination. At that time there was a store, Divine Antiques, run by Virginia Jennewein, in the basement. The rest of the home was unoccupied. He stopped to look in but was refused permission to see the rest of the interior. In response, he made the rash statement that he would etch and donate the glass for the front door should it be restored. The woman in the antique store replied, “Anybody that damned crazy can go in.” A few years after that, Sharpe remembers visiting Floyd Hardware and found Don in a state of alarm. "He was grieving that the Bellamy mansion in Wilmington had been the victim of arsonists. The fire in the mansion which occurred during the early ‘70s came at a time of racial troubles, and Don deeply feels the irony of this because the house is an example of the genius of Black artistic craftsmanship, one of the finest Greek revival buildings in the entire South.”
More recently, Don took on the task of reproducing skeleton keys for the four adult bedroom level closets. The term ‘skeleton key’ refers to any key that can open multiple locks. Incidentally, closets were present in Europe from the 1500s but were usually whole rooms. America refined the idea into reach-in closets within walls in the mid 1800s. Early clothes closets employed pegs, although Thomas Jefferson reputedly had a hanger device in Monticello. One fine story of invention is that in 1903, Albert J. Parkhouse of the Timberlake Wire and Novelty Company in Jackson Mississippi, couldn't find a spot to hang his coat and upgraded the clothes peg idea by twisting wire into the shape we recognize as the modern hanger. Whatever the truth of these details, the Bellamy's locking closets, like the gasoliers and fixtures Don also fixed, were part of the ever-evolving world of domestic living.
The original mirror frames were finished with gold leaf. During the 1970s and 80s, while restoring the frames in his home workshop, the gilt would catch Don's eye and take his thoughts back to those original glory days of the house. He added that thinking of that Civil War era also called to mind the quote from Winston Churchill that, “History is written by the victors.” While considering the thousands of lives that were lost on both sides, Don laments there are no victors in war. In his view, both Confederates and Yankees came away physically and mentally crippled. Taking on an historic preservation project, which takes much time and attention to detail, often leads to reflection on the lives of those who came before. Another tricky project was the restoration of the molding above the gasoliers. The parlor gasoliers were lit with coal gas, a by-product of naval stores processing. The medallions above the gasoliers were decorative, but served a practical purpose in hiding soot from the coal gas. The original medallions above the front parlor gasolier were, Don notes, "shaken loose by a group of kids on a tour in the house jumping up and down on the floor of the room above.” They had to be cleaned up and, in some cases, recast in plaster. Don shared some memories about restoring these and the similarly involved crown molding in the foyer. Doing the work at home, it attracted the attention of some neighborhood kids who asked if they could help. He let them pour some of the molding material and before it dried, he invited the kids to put their names on the backs of the molds. That idea came from the discovery, during Preservation NC's 1990s restoration, of the 'WBG' initials on the back of an original piece of plaster in the house. The story of it's discovery and the man who inscribed it is a mainstay of museum tours today. WBG was William Benjamin Gould, an enslaved plasterer who worked on many antebellum homes in the Wilmington area, including Bellamy's, and made a daring escape downriver in 1862. Letting the kids etch their names was a nod to this fascinating history and Gould, the skilled enslaved craftsman who had originally created this beautiful plasterwork in 1860.
Check out some pictures of the mansion and slave quarters restoration. Our website features a before and after gallery here. There you can appreciate Don's decades of work, as well as that of many other preservation experts.
The Robert R. Bellamy House. Of Eliza and John Bellamy's 10 children, Robert Rankin Bellamy (1861-1926) was the only one born in what is now the main house of the Bellamy museum at 503 Market St. He grew up in the house and became a successful drug store owner and pharmacist in downtown Wilmington. Robert had his own Queen Anne style home built next door to the original Bellamy mansion around 1895. Robert married Lilly Dale Hargrove (1862-1934) and they had one child, Hargrove Bellamy (1896-1994) in the house at 509 Market St. The picture below is approximately 1905. As you can see, it was a large and imposing structure. The Rachel Thompson house (513 Market St., far right in the historic image above and painted yellow in the present day image below) was bought by Robert Bellamy in 1890 as a rental property. He enlarged that house over time. Robert's house burned on Christmas Day in 1980 while in use as a home for children with disabilities, according to the local paper. At that time the building was known locally as the Tabb mansion. The building was lost but no-one was hurt. The John D. Bellamy Jr. House. One block away from the current museum site, at 602 Market St., sat the John D. Bellamy Jr. house. John Jr. (1854-1942) grew up in what is now the museum's main house. He was an attorney and politician whose election to the US House of Representatives was an integral part of the 1898 massacre and coup. Bellamy had acquired an imposing Italianate, James F. Post designed, 1858 house (Wright-Harriss-Bellamy) on the south east corner of 6th and Market sts. in the 1890s. Around 1899 he massively remodeled it in an extravagant, late Victorian, Queen Anne style. A tower, referred to locally as the ‘German helmet’, and decorative porches were added. The renovation, by noted local architect Charles McMillen, was equally grand on the inside. The local newspaper marveled at the elaborate oak, cherry, and mahogany interior woodwork, a ball room that was created on the top floor, and paneled silk, onyx fireplaces and tapestries by decorators Duryea and Potter of New York. A circa 1901 image shows the enormous changes to the house. As well as the tower, chimneys, porches, roof, gables and many other features that were rebuilt, there was interior paneling, wainscoting, ceiling beams, and mosaic tiles in both the vestibule and new conservatory. Walls and ceilings were either painted with floral designs or covered with paneled silks or tapestries. On Monday, March 13 ,1972 the original Bellamy mansion, now the museum, suffered an arson attack. While there was no evidence of arson, John Jr.'s house burned down on Wednesday, August 23rd, 1972. John Bellamy Jr's grand-daughter, Emma Bellamy Williamson Hendren (1902-1992) lived in the house at the time. Again, fortunately, no-one was injured. 1972 image from New Hanover County Public Library by way of Beverly Tetterton's book, Wilmington: Lost But Not Forgotten. The Wilmington Morning Star for August 24, 1972 reported, "The German helmet is gone now. It was among the first sections of the house to fall. The 'spike' atop the 'helmet' toppled down into the body of the building." Credits for information and images to Beverly Tetterton, Wilmington Lost But Not Forgotten (2005), Susan Taylor Block, Cape Fear Lost (1999), New Hanover County Library North Carolina Room collections, the Wilmington Star-News archives, and the Bellamy Museum archives.
Since 2015, the Bellamy Mansion Museum has conducted free, place-based school tours in February and March for New Hanover County 5th graders. Staff and volunteers showed students both the 1859 slave quarters and 1861 main house to describe how life looked before electricity, or even running water. "As the 5th grade curriculum changed, tour attendance dropped, so we decided to revisit the program," explains Jen Fenninger, Education & Engagement Director. "In collaborating with New Hanover County Schools, [headquartered in Wilmington, NC], museum staff learned that the 1898 Wilmington Massacre and Coup has become of increased emphasis in the 8th grade social studies curriculum. With that in mind, recalibrating the tour to target 8th graders became a major initiative in the last year." With financial support from Bellamy Mansion Museum board members, local 8th grade teachers were invited to the museum and offered a paid day of professional development. The conversation focused primarily on the enslaved individuals who had lived on the site and extended to the 1898 massacre and coup. The Bellamy site lends itself directly to the teaching of these local history topics. During the development session, teachers were offered a 90 minute tour, an 1898 presentation, resource guide materials, and museum staff perspectives on how to teach topics of historical slavery and race through the site. "We had a great discussion and gained information about the topics to target and they how they can be paralleled with the curriculum content," Jen says. "In subsequent months, we rewrote our script to be appropriate and useful to the 8th grade classes." Through this process, Jen notes, "we were also able to increase our collaboration with colleagues at the nearby Cape Fear Museum (CFM). CFM has an 1898 field trip at a similar time of year that includes a mapping activity and timeline of events. The Bellamy site and CFM's artifacts and documentation blend well into a more complete picture of this period of history and the themes that arise. The new partnership has widened our reach within the county. From our day with local teachers, we learned that it is difficult for them to complete a field trip that isn't a full day out of their school building. Now, with students attending both museum locations, they experience a fuller, more versatile field trip, and learn in buildings where enslaved people once lived and worked." --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- " I cannot say thank you enough to everyone who played a part in the field trip! It was so well organized and put together. The adults and students really had a great time! I spoke to many of the students, and most of them said it was a 9 out of 10. Overall, the experience was incredible!" Trask Middle School teacher ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Bellamy staff is supporting further efforts to educate teachers not only locally, but across the state by participating in symposiums held by the North Carolina History Center on the Civil War, Emancipation & Reconstruction out of Fayetteville, NC. With instruction coming from local historians, including Leslie Randle-Morton, associate director of the Bellamy Museum, the center held a two-day symposium last month in Wilmington. The purpose of the symposium is to teach historical perspectives on the war - its central point being that it was fought to preserve the system of enslavement. The Center reinforces this proven fact and ensures today’s school children learn the truth about the motivations behind the Civil War. The overall mission of the NC History Center on the Civil War, Emancipation & Reconstruction is to tell the stories of all North Carolinians and create a comprehensive, fact-based portrait of history that spans the Antebellum, Civil War, and Reconstruction periods. The Center is planning to hold a total of 12 symposiums as a lead up to the opening of a state historic site at the Fayetteville Arsenal where U.S. General William Tecumseh Sherman destroyed the Confederate Army’s ability to make weapons. Once the center is complete, which is expected in 2027, it will be turned over to the state and be housed within the museums division of the Department of Natural and Cultural Resources. |
Older Blog Posts
To see all previous blog posts, please click here. Blogs written after summer 2020 will be found on this page. AuthorOur blogs are written by college interns, staff, and Bellamy volunteers. Archives
November 2024
Categories |